Valakis vs. Menk: Who Wins?

A few days ago, when I reviewed the Enterprise episode Dear Doctor, we all wondered if the Menk were indeed genetically destined to become their world's dominant species or if the Valakians would find a way out of their genetic dead end.

For the answer, we have to go to The Complete Atlas of Star Trek:
Well, there you go. The planet is eventually overrun with Menk, but the Valakians still hold on as a small, but noticeable minority. More than that, the rechristened Menk planet became a Federation member in 2236, some 30 years before the TOS era.

Comments

snell said…
So, in just 85 years, the Menk go from being "relatively primitive" and uneducated to warp technology? I guess they really were as gifted as Phlox said (unless the Valakians were already close to warp, and the Menk just piggybacked their way in...)

The TNG episode Attached tells us the Kesprytt III situation is unprecedented, so in this case the Menk and Valakians must have BOTH joined the UFP. It's nice to see they get along...
Siskoid said…
The Menk were so adorable that eventually the Valakians just handed over the keys and changed the name of the planet.
snell said…
Or, knowing Star Trek science, they found a way to interbreed, and the infusion of menky goodness saved the Valakians...